I watched all of England's games, they played like Sh!te throughout the tournament. They didn't play all that well in the pre-tournament matches. Their attack was generally uninspired, the defense was weak, and they made lots of errors which resulting in drawing matches they should have easily won.
Mmarsh: Most England fans would agree with you, but they expect too much of a team which they expect to win the world cup but is rated quarter final status on ranking.
I think your analysis tends to assume the game goes on as much as before irrespective of specific events. Football doesn't work this way. 2-0 down then getting one goal and being disallowed the second must have a bad psychological effect on the players. Events can change games. Have you ever seen one team dominate for one period then the whole thing turn around? Take the Brazil - Holland game for example.
Germany, were overwhelmingly better only in one respect, being able to outrun the defence especially on the break, and the longer the game went on the more opportunities arose since England had to gamble and move forward. I think there was a lack of speed at the back, and Germany noted this during the US game.
Match Statistics
Let's get some objective evidence. Here are the match statistics, the first number refers to one team the second the other. Obviously I have removed the important goals which were scored by the above tactic and circumstances described. Now can you tell be if the first number refers to Germany or England?
Shots on Target 6 7
Shots off Target 7 6
Blocked Shots 4 5
Corners 4 6
Fouls 7 6
Offsides 4 2
Yellow Cards 1 1
Red Cards 0 0
Passing Success 78.8 78.2
Tackles 22 20
Tackles Success 59.1 70
Possession 44.8 55.2
Territorial Advantage 52.6 47.4
Does this suggest that any one team was outplayed or simply the defence was stretched out, or that one team was better at finishing than the other, essential that criteria is?
Regarding the qualification rounds, even the England fans were pleased with the teams progress, scoring 27 points out of a possible 30, only Spain did better. Perhaps that's the reason for the disappointment?